Adelaide Literary Magazine - 11 years, 96 issues, and over 3800 published poems, short stories, and essays

AM I THE HEART-SHAPED SHELL

ALM No.96, December 2026

ESSAYS

Terri O'Neil

11/20/20265 min read

yellow sunflower field during daytime
yellow sunflower field during daytime

Left or right?

I offered my left hand, palm turned upwards, and the stone of abundance was placed into its centre with a hurried tenderness. Both conscious that my departure was drawing close, I found myself hoping there had been something in that giving that words themselves couldn't, or wouldn't, speak. The shabby kitchen of the church hall, where the ordinary moments between us had so often given way to something resembling expansion, is behind us now. Time has carried us beyond that room.

And now, sitting shoulder to shoulder, I find myself searching for an indication of what that gesture had meant to him, hoping it had been an admission of something he could not bring himself to say then, but might be able to now. His eyes don’t touch mine, and this avoidance has begun to feel deliberate, familiar. We aren’t close enough to touch, a conscious stance on his part, but we’re close enough for me to feel that there exists a living vibration drawing breath beside me, a breath I want to reach towards. I’m nervous and feel that trembling thrum within, repositioning myself this way and that, altering my posture in search of something that resembles calm. Something that resembles him. My hands, however, are unmoored, unsure of where to settle, an anchor that scrapes along the seabed but cannot find purchase. I tuck them silently beneath my legs.

I steal glances to my right, where he sits, searching for some sign of shared unease, some sign that this weighs on him, too.

Nothing.

Instead, his gaze drifts between the tub of sorbet nestled in his palms and some point straight ahead, as though he is either willing himself to speak or patiently anticipating the words I have prepared for him. Someone has to go first, and given that I invited him here, those odds are on me. I look again at his hands, and the way that they allow the tub of sorbet to balance gently between his fingers.

Abundance. I say, giving the silence something to hold. A brief delay and an exhalation later, he sits more upright, his gaze fixed somewhere beyond me, to a place my eyes can’t reach.

I used to have a shell once, he says, and then pauses. Carrying either the quiet reverence of a monk or the easy fluency of a story told too many times before. I found it in a forest somewhere, it was buried beneath the dirt. It was beautiful and it was in the shape of a heart. I took it home, drilled a hole through it and wore it around my neck every single day.

He places the wooden spoon in the empty sorbet tray and moves the distraction to his right.

Hands unburdened, he now gesticulates as he continues. One day, I was climbing a fence and the necklace must have snapped, broken or fallen off. Lost beneath the foliage or else found its own way back home to the earth. Sighing, he says, I searched for it everywhere. Couldn’t find it. I’d lost it, it was gone. The moment lingered.

I felt afraid of what I might discover if I reached for the meaning beneath his words. I believed there was something in this telling that had been carefully chosen for me. That it wasn't an invitation to respond or to untangle its meaning, but an invitation to listen.

But there’s a quiet discomfort in being someone that yearns for meaning, so hoping my question might lead us somewhere the silence could not, I asked: were you sad?

Yes, he said. His intonation is sharp and visceral. I was devastated. I was devastated about it for years. I was so attached to that thing. And it was just a necklace.

And something in me began to sink even deeper. I had been listening for words that might bring us closer, but instead found myself confronting the possibility that there was nothing to move towards.

You don’t have to be attached, he said. With abundance, there is more, there is always more. I was broken when I lost that necklace, but I didn’t need to be. It wasn’t mine to keep and it wasn’t mine to hold on to.

I sat beside him on that wooden bench, its narrow frame bearing our combined weight, though the weight of what I hoped would be reciprocated emotion seemed to rest entirely with me, and entirely unreciprocated. I can't recall whether I straightened my back, trying to preserve some semblance of pride as the sun cast its light on this truth, or folded further into myself, embarrassed by how much I’d tried to give reality to something I had imagined. A fantasy that since its embryonic beginnings, had me suspended between ambiguity, obsession and hope.

I realised then that any attempt to probe further and unblur the lines, was futile. I sat, mute. He glanced at his watch, signalling that our time was up, oblivious to how indelibly these words would remain with me.

Relieving the bench of our combined weight, we stood slowly and began to walk forward, the pace hurried and hurtful. He strode a little further ahead, while I trailed behind, one unbalanced foot in front of the other, in a kind of emotional fuzz that I can only now recognise as the disorientation of a freshly broken heart.

And perhaps somewhere in that confusion, I wanted to believe that my leaving would hurt him in the ways it was hurting me. Perhaps what I wanted, more than anything, was to be loved by this man as he had loved his heart-shaped shell. I wanted to believe that the loss of me, too, would be one of devastation for him. That once I was gone, he would climb fences and dig beneath the dirt with his bare fingers to find me, to find some speck of me that he could wear around his neck, and that he would hold on to me as I had held on to him.

As time has passed and I’ve waited for some sign that I am the heart-shaped shell, I’ve been left with the silent traces of his detachment. I’m not his heart-shaped shell, and he’s not coming to find me.

And still, some part of me waits for him to come looking. To discover that it is me he cannot bear to lose. To realise that I am here, sitting on a blanket in a recently lawned park, arms outstretched and waving, as I always have been.

Perhaps the heart-shaped shell I have been waiting to become for someone else is one I might learn to hold for myself. Yet knowing this and feeling it are two entirely different things.

Terri O’Neil was raised in East London and has always been fascinated by the complexities of the human experience. An avid reader and reflective writer, she is drawn to stories that explore identity, relationships and the moments that shape who we become. She enjoys capturing personal experiences through writing, particularly those that challenge her perspective, inspire growth and leave a lasting impression on the person she is becoming.

Subscribe to FREE digital flip copy of the Adelaide Magazine printed edition.