Adelaide Literary Magazine - 11 years, 96 issues, and over 3800 published poems, short stories, and essays

FORGIVENESS LIKE A RIVER FLOWS

ALM No.96, December 2026

SHORT STORIES

Presley Acuna

11/21/202615 min read

white and brown train door
white and brown train door

I blinked as I read the cream-colored card stock inviting me to George’s 50th birthday cruise around Manhattan. I hadn’t thought about him in years.

“You look like you’ve just read a ransom note, Gib,” teased Jennifer from the kitchen table.

I conjured a smile. “Nothing that scary. But we are invited to my high school buddy’s 50th birthday party.”

Jennifer laughed and signaled to pass her the card. “I would say that qualifies as scary, from what I know about that gang of knuckleheads.”

I handed her the invitation and went to the counter to grab a coffee.

“George Esposito,” said Jennifer. “Wasn’t he the guy you got into a hallway brawl with?”

I nodded, “That’s him. It’s also how we got to be friends.”

“How Hollywood,” she quipped.

“Being buds with George led to a lot of things. A lot of antics.”

“So do you want to go to this?” she asked.

“I don’t know. Not sure I want to find out what George became.”

“Or the rest of them.”

“Yah, that too. I wonder if they’ll all be there.”

“Sounds like you want to find out, Gilberto my dear.”

The weather was restless the night of the cruise. We stood in line waiting to board the boat, dressed in cocktail party clothes as the humid summer air blew at us in random gusts.

“Well at least it’s a couple of notches above a Circle Line,” said Jennifer, appraising the boat.

Finally aboard, we were enthusiastically greeted by two women. The younger exclaimed upon seeing me, “Gib! You came! Do you recognize me?”

It was George’s sister but I couldn’t remember her name. I blanched, but fortunately her excitement would not wait. “It’s me, Toni! And you remember my Mom...”

I bowed slightly. “Mrs. Esposito, I…”

She shooed my words away. “Call me Alessi. You’re a grown man now, Gib.”

“You look great Mrs., I mean, Alessi.”

Not waiting for her mother to respond, Toni swept us towards the main cabin, where linen covered tables were arranged.

“I can’t believe I’m looking at you! Look how much you’ve grown,” Toni gushed, scanning me up and down and glancing perfunctorily at Jennifer, who had on her best New England mannequin mask on.

I faked my way forward, “I haven't laid eyes on you in decades, Toni. You look great!”

“You too, Gib! Only with short hair and nice clothes!”

I surrendered a chuckle, and turned towards Jennifer. “This is my wife, Jennifer.”

Toni locked eyes with Jennifer and offered her ring encrusted hand. “So great to meet you, Jennifer. You’re a lucky gal.”

“By some accounts,” answered Jennifer in kindling dry deadpan.

Toni ignored this and led us to a table near the rear of the room. Someone was already sitting there. Toni smiled at the other guest and said, “Sit anywhere. Introduce yourselves. I’ll let George know you’re here.”

Toni fluttered away. Examining the layout, I decided we would sit with our backs to the windowed wall, giving us a full view of the room. I pulled a chair for Jennifer.

“I know what you’re thinking,” said the other guest. He was broad shouldered with a thinning scalp of coiffed black hair. He wore a magenta collared shirt with ivory snaps and a large, expensive looking watch.

I sat down next to Jennifer and we both smiled at our table-mate, expectant.

“You don’t like surprises,” he said.

“I like to see who’s around,” I replied.

He extended his hand, rising slightly from his chair. “Name’s, Argo. I’m a friend of George’s. Used to drive for him.”

I raised an eyebrow. “No kidding. I guess he really made it, huh, having his own driver and all.”

Argo smiled knowingly, “He’s connected for sure.”

Jennifer nudged my foot, sensing no-goodness.

A server sailed over and took our drink orders.

A moment of awkward silence. Argo turned slightly in his chair to look behind him, probably to compensate for the silence, or maybe to keep tabs on the room.

“So, what do you do now?” I asked, taking a sip from my water glass.

Argo returned his attention to Jennifer and me and chewed on the question for a second. Then he replied, “I’m retired.”

Just then another guest was ushered to our table. He was tall and lanky with a mop of stringy brown hair parted down the middle and tied into a pony tail. He wore a tan suit that was clearly someone else’s, judging from the fit. He sat down and nodded at each of us in turn.

When it became apparent that this was the extent of his repertoire, I offered, “Welcome to table 14, buddy! I’m Gilberto and this is my wife Jennifer. I’m a high school friend of George’s.”

“Oh yeah,” answered our new acquaintance, as if to realize he had more lines to recite. He offered his hand and a lopsided grin. “Mikey Tarantino, but you can call me ‘Sitch’”

“Related to Quentin?” asked Jennifer.

Sitch just blinked at her.

“Why ‘Sitch’, Sitch?” I asked, to break the awkward silence, but also genuinely curious.

Sitch exchanged a look with Argo, who simply shrugged. Sitch absorbed that, turned to us and answered, “It’s cuz I’m good with situations. George likes people who are good with situations.”

Jennifer barked a laugh then grabbed a napkin to wipe at her eyes. “Sorry, sorry, don’t know why that made me laugh.”

“I like that too,” I gamely answered. Taking a large snort of my just arrived bourbon. “Do you work for George?”

“Used to. Until a… situation caught up with me. But George went to bat and got me off.”

I already knew the answer but I asked anyway. “And what do you do now?”

“I’m retired.”

Just then the first mate rang the ship’s bell and the Captain announced that we were casting off. I turned around to look at the whitecaps visible on the Hudson and downed another swallow of bourbon. I scanned the room looking for any familiar faces but detected none.

“Let’s take a walk around the upper deck before it starts to rain, hon,” I said to Jennifer, who instantly agreed and finished off her Sidecar. Argo and Sitch gave us a nod and proceeded to huddle together about something or other.

“I think you were the only one dumb enough to show up, Gib,” laughed Jennifer as we climbed to the upper deck. Ignoring her slight, I continued to scan the crowd. It was windy on the viewing deck and the boat swayed a little more than I would have liked as it plied its away across the rough water. To the right was Manhattan, which meant we were sailing north and would probably head back via the East River on other side of the island or else the boat would turn once it reached the island’s northern tip and sail back to the dock.

Just then I spotted George, leaning casually against the bar near the prow of the boat and holding court with a gaggle of well-dressed men and woman who seemed to be enjoying his raconteuring.

I pointed out George to Jennifer and we snaked our way to the bar. When we were about 10 feet away, he spotted me and exclaimed in a booming voice, “Hey, look who it is! The Gibster! The man with the van, ha ha!”

I couldn’t help but smile at that. I had, indeed, owned a van back then, which I had decked out with a 4 way sound system plus carpeting, curtains, a green vinyl sofa and a large cooler for beer and provisions. It had been our party wagon and many a mission had been launched from there.

“The Gibster?” asked Jennifer, bemused by this new intel from my teenage past.

I shrugged. “I had a lot of nicknames.”

Looking back at George, I countered, “It’s been a long time, Bruiser.”

He chuckled appreciatively. “I haven’t been called that in decades.”

“Yeah that’s ancient history. I‘m just Gib now, George. We can pocket the nicknames.”

George’s eyes widened, then he relaxed and extended his hand to Jennifer. She offered hers in return and he kissed the back of it, surprising Jen. Standing back up, he appraised me and said, “You’re holding up pretty good, old buddy. Looks like you’ve done well on the home front too,” he finished, looking at Jennifer, who swayed slightly. She was getting tipsy.

“You too, George,” I lied. He was slightly overweight but dressed as if he was not, sporting tight slacks, and an open collared dress shirt with a thin gold chain bearing a crucifix. He had grown a light salt and paper beard but still bore the same dome of straight brown hair as he had during high school.

"We’ve got a lot of catching up to do!” I finished.

“Yeah, we should do that,” he replied. “Let me get you two some drinks and then let’s step over there and talk.” George snapped his fingers at the bartender and in short order the three of us were sipping drinks and leaning on the rail, the wind sweeping through our hair. Jennifer looked cold and it was indeed getting cooler as the wind picked up and the storm gathered. She took a big swig of her second sidecar.

George and I exchanged a few stories, with Jennifer listening along, reminiscing about high school antics and the rocknroll band we had at the time, which we had named “Clash” (before the “The Clash” actually existed, after which we changed our name to “Crash”). We moved forward in time, recounting college antics, early jobs, close shaves and epic wins.

Eventually, we arrived at the present. I decided to dive in head first. “Looks like becoming an attorney has been good to you, George.”

“I’ve earned my ducats, buddy,” answered George self-assuredly.

I continued, “We met your ex-driver downstairs. Nice to have a driver! What kind of law do you practice?”

George locked eyes with me. “Mostly criminal law. And criminal defense.” A silence. He took a draught of his drink. “It keeps me busy.”

“Criminal defense? As in a trial attorney?” asked Jennifer.

“Sometimes.”

“We met Sitch,” I ventured.

George’s eyes became opaque. “I look out for my people.”

“Who are your people?” asked Jennifer, unable to resist. “Are you a mob attorney?”

“Jennifer!” I shouted at her, “You just met the guy!”

“Oops!” said Jennifer, putting her palm to her mouth Betty Boop style.

Just then I noticed a vaguely familiar silhouette talking to a couple of people on the opposite side of the viewing deck. I recognized the slightly stooped curve of his spine and his Romanesque nose even at this distance. That had to be Matt Esposito, George’s cousin and once upon a time the lead guitar player in “Clash”, or should I say “Crash”.

And with that recognition came a flood of memories and an ocean of guilt as I thought back to that last summer before college.

* * *

The gang was bored. It was a hot August night and we were gathered around the van, which we had parked in front of a deli that we knew would sell us beer. George, Bags and Karl were there, as were Ray and a couple of dudes from his building named Jesus and ‘Nito. Those two liked to hang with us, mostly because we had cars and money to buy beer. They had access to weed, or as they called it, ‘herb’. Some of our girlfriends were also there, game and waiting for tonight’s gambit. Lorelai, who we all called Rory, and who was actually Ray’s sister, hung onto my arm; a sweaty adolescent beauty. Ray and Bags’ girlfriends, Debbie and Julie, were also in the mix. We were a bona fide crew with my van, Ray’s Camaro and George’s GTO waiting to caravan wherever we were going.

“PBRs, locked and loaded,” announced Bags as he dumped three six packs into my cooler, which I had pre-loaded with bags of ice. They were already cold so I reached in, grabbed one and chugged a good portion of it in one swallow.

“Pacing, Gibs,” said Rory, wagging a playful finger at me. “You’re kind of a mean drunk.”

I wiped my mouth with the back of my hand and offered her the rest of the can which she deftly finished off. “And you’re a horny drunk,” I countered. She laughed and punched my bicep.

“So, to where do we dare, brothers and sisters?” asked Karl in his languid stoner fashion.

“Somewhere we can smoke, for starters,” said George.

“Let’s head out to the bocce courts. It’ll be deserted,” offered Nick, but no one seemed excited by the idea.

“Nah, man, try again, that's nowhere central,” George replied.

“Yo, my parents are in P.R. all week,” said ‘Nito. “Let’s hit up their place and party down. Play some records, drink some beer, smoke, chill. Cool?”

Jesus bumped fists with ‘Nito.

“Yeah, I like it,” said Bags. “We can use your parent’s phone to call around and find out what else is going on.”

“That works for me!” I declared. “It’s a plan. All aboard!” I slapped ‘Nito on the back and climbed into the van. Rory pulled herself up and onto the shotgun seat, while Bags and Julie climbed into the back. I turned the key and the Steve Miller Band’s “The Joker” instantly blared out of my 4 way speaker system.

“Some people call me the space cowboy!” yelled Bags from the back. “Some call me the gangster of love!” the two girls replied loudly.

I revved the engine and reached for the cord I had rigged overhead, which when pulled, blared the locomotive horn I had installed on the roof of the van. Rory laughed uproariously. She loved it whenever I did that.

‘Nito and Jesus joined Ray and Debbie in his Camaro while Karl hopped into George’s GTO. Everyone revved their rides and we rolled out.

‘Nito’s parent's apartment was in the basement of the high rise he called home. Nito’s father was the superintendent. The place smelled of cooking grease and cigarettes, and the incandescent light bulbs gave off a slight yellow tinge, but the TV and the record player worked, and in short order a joint was getting passed around.

After a few rounds of that, George got up and flicked on the TV. He started changing channels rapidly. Debbie looked over, distracted by the changing channels.

“What do you want to watch TV for, George? Are we boring you? You want a ride home?”

“I’m looking for a concert or a stand up show. Why don’t you make yourself useful and get me a beer?” he retorted.

“Oh, I see,” she drawled as sarcastically as she could, not budging from her perch on the sofa. George glared and flicked his cigarette butt at her, just barely missing her.

“So when’s the next Crash gig, George?” persisted Debbie. You guys should be playing like now; I mean it’s like Saturday night. What’s up with that?”

“It’s not that easy, Deb. Lay off him,” I said. Truth was, none of us wanted to go through the trouble of shopping tapes and promoting the band. We’d had a handful of gigs -- some high school dances -- and one dive bar, but mostly the band was an excuse to party in George’s parent's basement more than a reality.

“And Matt’s talking about quitting the band,” I added.

“Loser,” growled George. I knew that part of the reason Matt was on the way out was the way George constantly demeaned his cousin’s playing and vetoed Matt’s song picks. Definitely some weird family shit going on between them.

“Yeah, but he can chop that guitar, bro,” said Karl.

“I’d like to chop his head off,” answered George.

“Now, now,” replied Karl, offering the joint to George. ”Here, take this. Relax and float downstream, man.”

Just then George landed on a newsflash about a couple of teenage girls who had been kidnapped and had just been rescued by the NYPD. “Hey check this out, they found those girls in an abandoned boat off Pelham Bay.”

“That whole Pelham Bay area, heading out to Orchard Beach, is pretty wild west,” said Nick. “I mean, it’s like three times bigger than Central Park and fifty times less crowded. The mob buries bodies there.”

“But there’s some pretty good spots to park!” added Bags, glancing at Julie, who smiled back.

And that’s when the evil idea for the mother of all pranks entered my mind. The gang loved dirty tricks. There was the night we filled all the locks of the school building with JB Weld. Took the locksmith quite a while to get at least one door open. And there was the night we replaced the toilet paper in every rest room with rolls of duct tape. That had been a good one.

But this one would go down in the annals for sure.

“Hey, what if we kidnapped Matt? Tonight.”

Everyone turned to look at me, like children waiting for the Jack in the Box to spring open.

George swiveled around to face me. “Go on.”

“I mean pretend kidnap, you know? Let’s tell him we’re going to Orchard to build a campfire and party on the water.”

“Why Orchard Beach?” asked Ray.

“Because it’s a good idea anyway, duh, but also because to get there you have to drive down Orchard Beach Road, which is a wooded road with no houses or anything. It’s just woods. We can stage the abduction there.”

“Holy crap, that’s like in another league of evil, Gib. I didn’t know you had it in you,” said Ray, impressed.

“Me neither,” said George. You could almost see the wheels turning in his head. “Who’s going to be the abductor?”

I looked at our crew and knew right away. “’Nito and Jesus, of course. They’ll talk in Spanish when they grab him. And they’ll wear face masks.”

George laughed out loud and went over to tousle ‘Nito and Jesus’s hair. “You’ll be perfect!” The two of them just shrugged, probably thanking the Lord it wasn’t them on the receiving end.

From there the crew was hooked. Planning continued at a fever pitch until we had it fully mapped out. Rory would call Matt and convince him to come out. Rory and I would go in the van to get him while ‘Nito and Jesus would be set up the ambush at a deserted spot along Orchard Beach Road. They would leave a flashlight on the ground to mark the abduction point.

I would tell Matt I had to pull over to take a leak or something. At this point, ‘Nito and Jesus would leap out of the woods holding plastic guns and abduct the three of us, yelling in Spanish, blindfolding us and tying our hands.

We would then be shoved into the back of the van and we would roar off towards the beach, Jesus at the wheel. By then Rory and I would be untied and unmasked and just playing along, trying not to laugh.

The rest of the crew would be waiting at the beach. Once we arrived, ‘Nito and Jesus would take Matt’s wallet and walk him to the water where they would tell him in broken English to walk in up to his waist. At this point, just as Matt would be touching the waterline with his shoes, Rory would run up and unmask him, revealing the ruse.

Long story short, we executed the plan flawlessly, except for the part where we thought Matt would laugh it off and life would move on. But he didn't laugh. He was upset. Very upset. He had really believed it was his last day and told us he considered us traitors. Then, sobbing and crying, Mike had turned and run away, hands still tied, until he was a dot on the horizon.

He quit the band and never spoke to any of us again.

That fall, I moved into my college dorm in rural Pennsylvania, which was about as far away as you could get from my former inner city life, and underwent many changes as I adapted to my new and larger world. I gradually came to see that what I had once considered an epic story of teenage mischief was actually a callous act of cruelty at the expense of someone who had trusted me. I had a hard time saying those words to myself and I wondered what I would say to Matt if I ever had the chance.

And now I had it.

* * *

“We’ll talk more later, Gib,” said George, looking sternly at Jennifer. He walked away, scanning the deck for anyone to talk to.

“Sorry about that, husband,” croaked Jennifer.

“Nah, don’t sweat it. He probably is a mob attorney! And tonight is probably the last time we’ll see him. We’re props to him.”

Jennifer peered at me over the rim of her drink and after a moment, nodded. The wind was really kicking up now and people were heading back down to the main deck. Rain was beginning to fall. It felt like the end of the party.

“Let’s head downstairs, Gib. Maybe the food is edible,” said Jennifer.

“You go ahead. Make friends with the ex-cons. That’s Matt Esposito over there,” I gestured. She looked towards Matt and pursed her lips. She knew the story and knew what I had to do.

I walked towards Matt, who was peering at the water as the boat began to turn around to return to the dock. The boat’s swaying was exacerbated by the turning and I had to hold onto the rail to get closer to him. I was almost next to him when he felt my presence and turned to face me.

“Hi Matt, long time,” I offered.

He paused a moment to take me in and finally replied, “Yup. A lifetime. Did you find George?”

Hmm. No ‘How are you?’. “Yeah, we talked. Lots of memories,” I replied, feeling stupid.

“Yup,” he said again, letting the rain and wind fill the void. I looked at him and watched emotions course under the surface of his face as that memory replayed in his mind. I also saw the years on his face. He had made a life, like all of us, and scabbed over the scars. I had no idea if he had talked with anyone else from the old crew and I didn’t care. I only wanted my own absolution.

I was suddenly struck by the irony of where I was, surrounded by water like Mike had been that night on Orchard Beach, comingling with the kind of people who kidnapped for real and killed without compunction and only worried the tedious details of burying the bodies. I felt more than ever the need to apologize to Matt for what we did to him so long ago.

I cleared my throat. “What are you doing these days, Matt?”

“I’m a dentist,” he replied.

“That must be very ful-filling,” I ventured, trying to lighten the mood. Nothing.

“Say Gib, did you think I’d be here?” he abruptly asked.

“No.”

He nodded, smiling thinly. “I wondered if any of you would show.”

“Listen, Matt, I want you to tell you that I…”

Matt raised his palm. “Gib, I know.”

“You do?”

“I do. I found out that whole thing was your idea. I hated you for years for that.”

“Matt, I’ve hated myself…”

“I forgive you,” he quietly rasped.

The boat swayed again and I stumbled, grasping for a handhold. Matt watched with interest and looked over the rail, assessing the choppy water.

He turned back at me and made to leave. Just as he walked past me he said, “Careful you don't drown, bro.”

Presley Acuna is a writer, musician, actor and technologist. He is an Ecuadorian-American, born and raised in New York City and currently living in Brooklyn. He writes genre fiction as well as stories based on his own life experiences. His stories have appeared in The Rockvale Review, The Raven’s Perch, Spank the Carp and others.

Subscribe to FREE digital flip copy of the Adelaide Magazine printed edition.