Adelaide Literary Magazine - 11 years, 96 issues, and over 3800 published poems, short stories, and essays

I HATE DAVID SEDARIS

ALM No.96, December 2026

ESSAYS

Sarah Doudna

11/20/202617 min read

Last week, I was making Thai Kabocha Squash Soup while listening to Sedaris’s book Calypso. The squash softened as I cooked it with coconut milk, but his personal stories so distracted me that it came out bland and weedy. This was particularly annoying because I was making the soup for my friend, who was coming to visit me from North Carolina. I’d cooked for two weeks, filling my fridge and freezer with all my favorites: White Bean and Ham, Cauliflower Carrot Ginger, Spicy Chicken Pozole, and what I had now renamed Bland Squash Muck.

Sedaris’s high-pitched nebbish tones irritated me as he insulted and gossiped about his family members and husband right and left. I couldn’t help but get pissed off on their behalf. It began to affect me more than just ruining some soup. I couldn’t concentrate on simple tasks. When buying theater tickets for my friend’s visit, I bought them for the wrong night. To top it all off, my friend got sick and couldn’t come. I can’t be 100% certain Sedaris didn’t infect her, but the soup and tickets were all his doing. I blamed Sedaris for ruining my weekend; that is when I decided that I hated David Sedaris.

Maybe David’s family doesn’t care that he talks about them. They all seem to have an amazing sense of humor. Do they see his insults as a sort of sarcasm? Or is it irony? I get those two mixed up. I can be very literal-minded. I don’t always catch when a person is joking, and I’ve been accused of not having a sense of humor.

I’ve always been a little bit dingy in that way. It’s sort of the way Teri Garr or Lisa Kudrow do ditzy. When I was young and blonde, people said I looked like one or the other. Baby Boomers said I reminded them of Teri Garr. But Gen-Xers said I looked like Lisa Kudrow and asked all the time if I was her. I even had people run up and snap photos of me and run away. When Friends was very popular, someone once sang “Smelly Cat” near me on a crowded train, and everyone in that car turned like a sea parting down the center, all staring and laughing at me. Their giggles sounded like a laugh track, as if I were playing the role of Lisa Kudrow on the subway.

More than looks, we have similar mannerisms and speaking styles. Teri Garr played Lisa Kudrow’s mom on Friends. And really, if Teri Garr and Lisa Kudrow had gotten together and had a baby, it would be me. But of course, that’s totally impossible because they’re both actually funny. So of course, I resent David Sedaris for being hilarious.

Sedaris brags about how, when he was a kid, he would flush the empty toilet paper rolls down the toilet. When the pipes eventually clogged, he’d watch with glee and horror as his dad removed the porcelain throne from the floor and dug his hand into the stinking hole underneath to pull them out. And then David would do it again. He pissed his dad off on purpose. When I was a kid, I loved my parents and wanted to please them. I never would have disrespected them in that way. I mean, sure, I accidentally blew up the family car, but it wasn’t intentional.

One day on my way to second grade, I was sitting in the back seat of our VW hatchback playing with a pen, and when I unscrewed it, a tiny spring fell out. Who knew pens contained such mechanisms? I tried to grab it, but it lodged itself like a crumb between the thick vinyl of the seats. When I dug my fingers into the crevice, I only pushed it farther in, and it was gone.

A week later, during morning recess, I was surprised to see my mom standing on the covered walkway outside the principal's office at school. She looked worried, and in that setting with so many kids around, she seemed even taller and thinner than she did at home. She said she’d been driving downtown when smoke started pouring out of the dashboard. She’d parked on the side of the road and walked a mile up to the school to call our mechanic. She was still there, chewing the inside of her lip, when the bell rang, and I had to go back to class. After school, my parents came home together in Dad’s blue Toyota. Where was our little tan car?

A woman in a house across the street had seen my mother park, and soon after she’d walked away, the car had burst into flames.

John, our trusty mechanic who owned the 76 station on Kaumana Drive, investigated the cause of the fire. The design of the original Volkswagen placed the engine, not under the hood, but in the back. For the model we had, that meant under the seats. John discovered that something had fallen into the engine and ignited a spark that caused the fire, and it was... a tiny metal spring.

It had been my fault. But I certainly wasn’t going to announce it to anyone. That was just for me to hold in my heart and subsequently use as evidence that I was culpable for everything that ever went wrong around me for the rest of my life. Unlike Sedaris. He shows no compunction for his actions which is infuriating.

In high school, I got a job at Little Caesars Pizza, making what seemed like a great fortune of $4.75 an hour. I had gotten the job because my friend Anna worked there. I filled in at various stations, first preparing the pans for the sour-smelling dough, which required three pump-fulls of oil into their signature square pans, until I spilled, and oil poured down the front of my olive green work pants, which forever after stank of grease.

Eventually I graduated to topping the pizzas. Though the manager didn’t like that I added too many pepperonis. We were only supposed to put five on a small, and seven on a medium, which I thought was chintzy. I loaded it up the way I would want it. And then the manager would again show me the corporate way, while I rolled my eyes behind his back.

When Kimo left, I had to help wash dishes with Dirk, a station that required two people. We dipped the dishes into the hot soapy water, and then into the rinse water side of the sink, and finally into the tub of weak bleach solution to sterilize them, our hands turning red and scaly from the heat and chemicals, all the while chatting and joking around. At least we did until after the Big Drug Deal incident.

My friend Anna asked Dirk to take us and our other friend Maria for a ride home after the county fair. We all thought Dirk was So Cool because he had a car.

He picked us up around 9 p.m. after we’d been twirled on my favorite ride, The Zipper. The air was filled with the sweet smell of cotton candy and the sound of kids laughing and screaming. At first, it was fun. We were fifteen- and sixteen-year-old girls giddy to be in the car with an older guy. Dirk was twenty. Soon, he turned off the main road and went speeding through stop-signed streets in a rough neighborhood with his headlights turned off. It was thrilling like The Zipper, and then terrifying. His logic was we’d see other cars coming because they would have their lights on. One would hope.

Out of nowhere, Dirk turned, and we bumped over potholes in a driveway until he came to a stop. There were no other cars and no lights on in the house, but he got out, saying he’d be right back. When he didn’t return, Anna said it was fine, Dirk was cool. But after forty-five minutes dragged by Maria burst into tears, afraid to be late for her 11 p.m. curfew. As the oldest, I was elected to go in and get him.

A streetlight from the road was the only light as I climbed the stairs with growing unease. At the top, a huge, vicious-looking pit bull slept on the threshold. But it didn’t bark or even raise its head, and merely blinked as I leaned forward and peered in the screened door. Dirk was sitting on a couch, his back to me, next to an enormous Hawaiian man sitting nearby on a low, wide chair.

“Come on in!” The man called out to me.

My breath stopped. But he’d seen me now, and I’d have to go in. Fueled by Maria’s tears, I stepped over the dog and closed the screen door behind me.. As I came closer to them, I saw that Dirk’s lap was covered with a pile of little plastic packets of white powder. I tried to play it cool as it dawned on me that the packets most certainly contained drugs. Cocaine, maybe? I calmly sat in an adjacent chair as if drug deals were an ordinary thing in my life, while my mind raced. Were there going to be guns? Was he going to kill us? Dirk and the giant man, who seemed nearly as wide as he was tall, continued to laugh and talk until I very gently suggested that we needed to get going.

As we stood up, Dirk gathered the pile of packets into the bottom of his t-shirt, holding it up like a pouch, the way my sister and I did when we picked guavas. One of Dirk’s teeny plastic baggies of white powder had fallen under his chair. The massive dealer saw me notice it and gave me a look and a smile as if to say, “This is just our little secret.” I was too afraid to point it out to Dirk. I did not want to piss off the drug dealer. I just wanted to get the hell out of there.

Relief flooded my system as we returned to my friends. But Dirk wouldn’t start the car. Anna was riding shotgun, and Maria and I sat in the backseat looking at each other, our eyes sharing anxieties. We waited for him to get settled, but he was getting more agitated.

I leaned forward in my seat and looked from Anna to him. “What’s going on?”

“One is missing!” He hissed.

I sat back quickly. Should I tell him I’d seen that a packet had fallen to the ground? I just wanted to go home. “Umm, I think maybe I might have seen one under your seat?”

“Where?” He frantically dug under the driver’s seat.

“No…it was when we were in the house.”

He started swearing, got out of the car, and went back up the stairs, the screen door banging behind him.

He eventually came out, and we left, but Maria was late for her curfew. A week later, we learned that her mom had forbidden her from hanging out with us.

David Sedaris would never have gotten in this situation because he knows all about drugs.

After Dirk stopped speaking to me, they had me announcing the names of the customers as the pizzas came out of the oven. Despite having been on stage, I found this excruciating. The audience, that is to say, the customers, were not my parents and supportive friends, but angry, irritated adults only too happy to unleash their vitriol on a kid. I couldn’t hide behind a character; I just had to play myself.

We were backed up more than usual that day; people were waiting, sweating. When I started calling out the names, no one could hear me. “Louder!” said a grumpy man when I called out “Pacheko”. I felt my face get pink. It was chaotic, and the pizzas were piling up. “Hurry up.” The people were hot and tired. The next ticket looked like a joke. It read “Tampon.”

“This can’t be right.” I hissed to the expediter, showing him the tag.

Toby was grabbing the pizzas straight from the oven, shoving them into pizza boxes, and attaching the order tickets. It wasn’t that I couldn’t say the word without laughing. I couldn’t say the word at all, definitely not in front of a room of adults.

I hadn’t even told my mother when I got my first period. It was private. A sample box of pads had arrived in the mail a few weeks before, and I had ferreted them away, feeling my body changing and knowing it would come any day. When it did, I was prepared and didn’t have to ask anyone for anything. When I ran out, I confided my secret to my middle sister, she told me to put what I needed on the grocery list, and Dad would buy them when he did the shopping.

“DAD buys your tampons?”

“He doesn’t care.”

I imagined my father and the hair he combed over his bald spot searching the grocery store shelf for the blue box with the size I’d requested. The idea of my Dad knowing such things about me was horrifying. I vowed to save up my lunch money and buy my own.

Behind the counter, piled with hot pizzas, I skipped the one with the word “Tampon” — written in indecently large black ink — and went on to the next one, “Silva.” But because I’d skipped one, the pizzas were getting even more backed up.

“Say it.” Toby demanded.

Cringing, I looked down and murmured “Tmpn” into the collar of my black polo shirt with “Little Caesars Pizza” embroidered in orange on the left breast.

“What!!??”

“Speak up!” People were at their limit.

I remembered my mother’s explanation of menstruation and sex. “I’m not talking about blue jeans,” she said. But I didn’t know what genes were. I had pictured denim pants in various colors other than blue. Were they red, purple, yellow?

“Tampon?!” I finally called out, my face turning crimson. A well-to-do Filipino lady came forward, looking extremely agitated.

“That girl couldn’t say Tampon.” I heard someone laugh, and another giggled in response.

My face burned, and soon after, I gave my notice. David Sedaris wouldn’t have cared if people had laughed while he was saying Tampon. He probably would’ve shouted it just to get a reaction.

But the real reason I hated David Sedaris, was because he could make me laugh for two hours and then break my heart with a single sentence.

In his essay “A Number of Things,” David’s description of the last time he saw his sister, Tiffany, is so poignant, the scene haunted me. I thought about my friend Aliya. She said she’d done a lot of Reiki and energy healing when she’d first found the lump, and it went away. But then it came back. She didn’t want surgery or chemo. But who really wants either? “Got plans for the weekend?” “Yeah, I’m really looking forward to having chemo.” — said no one ever. She wanted positive energy, she said, and a miracle.

I met Aliya when I was dancing in Honolulu, and she was the dance captain. Her suggestions were specific and insightful, and I liked her immediately. She became one of my closest friends. She taught me to read lips so we could have entire conversations across the room during long rehearsals, her hands fluttering to punctuate her silent words. She was hilarious, charismatic, and fun.

For two Christmases, like David Sedaris, who worked as an elf at the Macy’s in New York City, we were Santa’s helpers at the Macy’s in Ala Moana Shopping Center in Honolulu. We helped our actor friend who’d been cast as Santa get into costume, the two of us ding-a-linging in our green, bell-covered hats and curly-toed shoes. He was so skinny, we wrapped bubble wrap around his middle so he’d fill out the Santa suit. The bubbles would pop, and he would make fart jokes, and we laughed until we cried.

When I moved from Honolulu to New York, Aliya knew I needed help. She magically showed up at my apartment hours before I needed to be at the airport. I was so nervous, I had everything piled on my bed. She sat calmly amidst the chaos, folding my clothes and tucking them into my suitcase along with gifts I found later when I unpacked. She nodded and listened as I ran my mouth and ran around the house for last-minute things, her long fingers with dark red nails rolling up my socks.

At the airport, when Aliya hugged me goodbye, I felt gutted not knowing when I would have the money to come back home.

Recently, my iPhone’s photo of the day was of Aliya and me when she told me about her cancer nine years ago. In the picture, we are sitting on a rock wall overlooking a surf spot. It’s a beautiful day; the waves roll in calmly, and the sky is cerulean blue. Looking at us, I can practically feel the warm breeze blowing off the ocean. Our smiles are soft and genuine, but I remember feeling really angry.

She had just told me about her cancer and made me promise not to tell anyone. She didn’t want to be judged for how she was handling it. She didn’t want to be harassed into following treatments that didn’t align with her beliefs. On one hand I understood. Aliyah was the healer at the theater whenever anyone sprained an ankle or injured their foot. She would do Reiki, and apply various healing salves, some that I still use.

I must have looked doubtful though because she warned me about other friends of hers who had insisted she go to a doctor and how she’d cut them out of her life. I didn’t want to create a rift between us. I wanted to support her and be there for her in whatever way she wanted. The last thing I wanted was to lose her.

“I don’t believe in Western Medicine,” she’d said, as if the words tasted bitter.

“And you would rather die than try it?” I fumed.

She looked scared and started to cry, but she nodded. She would rather die.

Why couldn’t she do both, I wondered, keep doing Reiki and energy work and whatever other homeopathic remedies, and at the same time have a lumpectomy. She didn’t have to believe in it. You don’t have to believe in Santa Claus to celebrate Christmas, do you? But she didn’t want surgery.

A few days later, at lunch, Eileen, a fellow dancer, complimented Aliya’s recent weight loss.

“It’s my new diet,” Aliya told Eileen, smiling with pride. She explained her focus on fruits and vegetables. I chewed my salad and chewed my thoughts. Help me help her, I silently begged. But Eileen didn’t know the truth, and because she was a nurse, Aliya wouldn’t let me tell her. I kept my eyes on my greens so my face would not betray me.

After Aliya told me about her cancer, and for the three years that followed, she and her mom traveled to Mexico for homeopathic remedies, to Italy and Brazil for herbs and blessings from shamans. Or shams, I thought to myself, but never said to her. They would pass through New York, and she would stay with me, and we’d catch a show, one of her favorite things. She excitedly showed me the remedies she’d invested in from Mexico. But when its effects did not last, she agonized over other methods and which to choose. To help her decide, she practiced an alternative medicine technique called muscle testing. She would ask questions of her subconscious while testing the strength of her fingers. The results would determine which method would work best: her life in her hands. I nodded, all the while feeling a terrible mounting despair.

By then, her cancer was growing through the skin, which is called an ulcerated tumor, and happens in later stages of breast cancer. Aliya would be teaching dance class and begin to bleed, and have to make an excuse to run to the bathroom to change the bandage. She was losing a lot of blood. And still, she barred me from telling anyone. “Not yet,” she said, over and over.

The last time she visited New York, I met her in Bryant Park, near my work. She looked tired. We sat at one of the metal tables. I asked about her health and how she was feeling, but she didn't want to talk about it. She was excited to be in the city. “Look! That building says ‘Grace,’” and she grabbed my hand and bounded up —“Let’s take a selfie.” She had a childlike enthusiasm for things like that — grace, light, dance, sparkles. She loved kids, animals, fairies, Christmas, and magic. In the photo, she looks triumphant and joyful, teaching me how to live life in the midst of her illness.

On the last night of that trip, Aliya insisted on showing me videos of some jazzy theater dances she had choreographed years before when she’d had her dance company. The music and movements were upbeat and sassy. They wore cowgirl costumes with skirts and boots and the dancers were having great fun. I was thrilled to get to see her dance company, which I’d heard so much about. She pointed out various people and told me stories about their shows. She was adamant that I learn the choreography.

“You’ll meet Emma and Sally and Gail and everyone. You’ll like them.”

I couldn't understand. I lived in New York, and they all lived in Hawaii. How would we ever dance together? Was she hallucinating?

When I visited her for Thanksgiving, she was using a walker. I told her mom, Helen, I would stay with Aliya over Christmas. Her older brother had been diagnosed with brain cancer, and Helen wanted to go to California to see her son. She was coping with both of her children dying of cancer at the same time.

At Christmas, I slept by Aliya’s side, on the edge of her bed, so as not to disturb her carefully arranged mountain of pillows that propped her in a position to minimize her pain. Her right arm was swollen with fluid, and I rubbed CBD oil into her skin and fetched her Elderberry Elixir.

Later she said she felt things were moving and changing and that maybe she had to get worse before she got better.

I tried to keep her hope alive, because what else was there? “Yes,” I agreed, “maybe things were turning around.” But deep down, she felt like sand slipping between my fingers.

Christmas morning, I lay listening to the rhythmic sigh of the oxygen machine she needed because the cancer was eating her lungs. There was no one to view this scene with me, the shock of how sick she was, how thin. There was just the light she kept on all night. I found myself feeling a kinship with that dragonfly lamp, with its purple and blue shade, sitting high on a bookshelf, witnessing it all.

Later, she was changing the bandage on her chest and showed me her wound. It was massive. I didn’t understand what I was seeing. There was no breast or skin, just a white-ish mass that looked plastic and hard where she had been soft and tanned. I thought of the time we went to see where lava had flowed over a beloved black sand beach on the Big Island. There was nothing to see; only scarred lava baking in the sun; the beach was just gone.

When her mom returned, I sat by Aliya’s bed waiting for another friend to pick me up. Although I had a few hours before my flight, I told them that I needed to go. I’m ashamed to admit that I couldn’t wait to leave the stuffy room crammed with things. I wanted to feel the sun on my face, the wind in my hair. I was overwhelmed with sadness. My mother had died earlier that year, and the thought of losing Aliya was excruciating. It hurt to leave, but it hurt to stay. Worse was wanting to say something profound, needing to say goodbye, but how could I if we hadn’t acknowledged that she was, in fact, dying. Seconds ticked by in 20-minute intervals, my thoughts speeding, and my lips still, my voice silent. I wanted to crush her to me in a hug, but that would have been far too painful.

Aliya died a week after Christmas, a week after I left. Three months later, her mother held a Celebration of Life for her. Aliya told her mom she wanted all her friends to dance together, performing her choreography. Aliya knew she was dying. She had been trying to tell me.

I berated myself, wondering endlessly if I could have done something different, anguishing that I did it wrong. Did I make the mistake, yet again of not speaking up like all the other times? Would David Sedaris have insisted she get medical help? Could I have saved her life? I imagined rewinding to the day she told me, instead saying, “I know you’re scared. I will go to the doctor with you. Let’s face this together.”

Seven years have passed since Aliya’s death. This past Friday, at another metal table in Bryant park, I had tea with a ballet student who had been away from New York for many months, caring for her mother. The hardest thing, she said, was accepting her mother’s choice not to have intervention for her breast cancer.

She sat straighter. “The doctor was very clear that the patient’s choice must be honored.” My friend felt no guilt. Why would she? She was honoring her mother’s wishes. Something clicked. I nodded, feeling suddenly lighter, a release of something held between my shoulder blades.

I opened a cellophane bag with macarons we bought from a nearby cafe and bit into the crisp outside and sweet, chewy center.

“How are you?” she asked me, appearing grateful to change the subject.

I told her that, coincidentally, I was writing a story about a friend who’d had breast cancer and also hadn’t wanted intervention, and I was trying to wrap it up. “Endings are always hard.” I had meant it in terms of writing, but tears now pricked at my eyes, and I scrambled to change the subject. “These are good,” I said, indicating the pastry, “and such a pretty color.”

My friend nodded, ignoring my tears. As graceful as her dancing, she let my words about endings float up into the tall trees surrounding the park. She examined the bright orange confection flecked with gold. “What kind are they?”

“Apricot,” I said, and she smiled.

Sarah Doudna teaches open level adult ballet classes in Manhattan and writes a blog called On the Way to the Barre about life lessons and dancing. Her writing has appeared in Halfway Down the Stairs, Cardinal Sins, Mojave Heart Review, and Ducts.org. She has read her stories aloud at the acclaimed Ducts reading series at the KGB bar in Manhattan. You can often find her walking in the park near her house and listening to stories by David Sedaris.

Subscribe to FREE digital flip copy of the Adelaide Magazine printed edition.