Adelaide Literary Magazine - 11 years, 96 issues, and over 3800 published poems, short stories, and essays

THE LETTER

ALM No.96, December 2026

SHORT STORIES

Teegan Weinstein

11/20/20264 min read

“You know what your problem is Barry?” asked Wally, while he ate cereal on the couch.

“Enlighten me,” I said, turning towards him from my desk.

“You think way to hard about things.”

“No, I simply just think about things, you should try it.”

Wally stuffed his face with cheerios. “Dude, I’m for real, you’ve been talking about this chick for like two years, either tell her how you feel or stop yappin about it.”

“First of all, it’s been six months, second of all, it’s not that easy”

“Sure, it is, and hey, if you’re that nervous about saying it to her face, you could always write a letter.” He picked up a notebook from the coffee table and tossed it to me.

“What, like it’s the 1920s or something?”

“It’s romantic. Trust me.”

“Alright Romeo, how many girls have you written a letter for?”

“Ugh, like I said, you think way to hard about things.” Wally stood up from the couch like a bear coming out of hibernation.

“Have you stood up once today?”

He yawned. “Look, tell her, don’t tell her, just stop being so scared.”

Wally walked off into his room. As much as I hated to admit it, he might have had a point. Writing it down might help me find the right words. So, for about 30 minutes I sat there, thinking of a way to start it.

Dear Lucy,

Too professional.

Hello Lucy,

Way too creepy.

Dear beautiful girl,

My god, that one was terrible.

Maybe Wally was right. I was thinking too hard. Eventually I just stopped thinking and began to write. I wrote about the night we met, all of our late phone calls, the way she laughs when I burp, I sort of blacked out. After I finished, I folded the paper up and for a second, I thought about what would happen if I actually sent it to her. Then, I realized I wasn’t totally insane. So, I left it on my desk while I went to sleep.

The next day I didn’t wake up until noon. I’m not sure what got into me but I just felt like it was the day. The day I told Lucy how I felt. The first order of business was to wipe that corny letter off the face of the earth and come up with something better to say. I went out to the living room where Wally was laid out on the couch. Then the unimaginable happened. The letter was gone. I looked all around the desk but it was nowhere to be found. My face went hot. If I found out someone had read that letter, I’m not sure what I’d do.

Wally noticed something was wrong. “You straight bare?”

“Where’s that piece of paper that was on my desk?”

Without looking away from the TV, Wally said, “Oh, I dropped it off at the mail room for you this morning.”

That might have been the worst combination of words I could have possibly heard. My stomach dopped to the floor and my heart felt like a jackhammer.

“You what?”

“Yeah, I saw it on your desk and figured you weren’t gonna do it. So, boom, I pulled the trigger for you. Relax, I didn’t re—”

I didn’t even hear him finish; I bolted out of my dormitory and headed straight for the mail room. By the time I got there I was sweating bricks.

“Hi, I need to retrieve a letter. It was brought here by mistake.”

“Okay, I just need the tracking number.”

“The wha—. I don’t have that. Someone else mailed it this morning.”

“Well, all the mail from this morning has already been processed. Its probably left the facility by now.”

“Please this is urgent, I need that letter back.”

The worker laughed. “What was in the letter sweetie?”

“It’s for a girl,” I muttered, reluctantly.

“Oh, I see, you’re not the first. I think she’ll be fine. Now it’s a long line. Next please!”

It’s not her I’m worried about.

People pushed in front of me until I was at the back of the line. I had only one choice. I needed to reach Lucy before the letter did. She lived about 5 miles away in the heart of Boston and the mail had a couple stops before it got to her. I didn’t have much time so I practically flew down the highway. Right before I got there, I called her.

“Lucy!”

“Hey Barry!”

“I’ll be there in five minutes, come outside”

“Wha—”

I hung up.

I had to park two blocks down and sprint to her building. When I got there, she was waiting outside and she looked as beautiful as ever. Suddenly, I remembered why she was worth all this trouble.

“Barry, what’s going on?” Lucy asked.

In that moment, completely out of breath. I thought about all the times Id imagined this conversation and how everything would be ruined afterwards. But it wasn’t until this moment that I thought about the possibility she might like me back. What if this whole time I was worried about nothing?

“Lucy…I really like you. Ive been terrified to admit it and honestly, I don’t know why I’m admitting it now but—”

I wasn’t even sure what else to say. All she did was stare at me for a few seconds.

“Barry, you came all this way, just to tell me that?”

“Well technically I came all this way to stop me from telling you and now I’m here and I just keep talking and talking and I can’t shut up—"

Lucy laughed. “You’re an idiot.”

“What?”

“Ive been waiting for you to ask me out for months.”

I couldn’t help but smile.

“So, dinner? Friday night? Perhaps when I’m less sweaty.”

“I’d like that. Oh, and here.” She pulled out the letter from her pocket.

“Y— you got the letter?”

“Wally texted. He said you’d flip out. It was beautiful Barry.”

Teegan Weinstein was raised in the Florida sun. He’s studying at Full Sail University for a degree in Creative Writing. When he’s not writing, he can be found enjoying films at the movie theater or hanging out with his dog, Django.

Subscribe to FREE digital flip copy of the Adelaide Magazine printed edition.